Skip to main content

Troublemakers

Reflection to Troublemakers by Carla Shalaby



Ageism has been generally defined as a prejudice people from a certain age group hold towards other age groups. How does ageism impact our classroom rules, procedures and management systems? How do our rules and procedures demonstrate what we think about younger people and their agency?
Image result for troublemakersAgeism impacts our classroom rules, procedures and management systems in multiple ways. Oftentimes, teachers delegate and students follow instructions. When a student disagrees with a rule, the teacher “wins”.  For students, the rules can indicate that teachers view students as incapable of making sound judgement calls. Students are taught that they must be guided and molded by teachers.
As they currently stand, our rules and procedures demonstrate negative beliefs regarding the agency and abilities of young people. We must change our rules and procedures to show our students that we see them as responsible, fully functioning adults, capable of making good decisions. One way to do so is to create rules with the class. When young adolescents are given a voice, they feel valued and important. Teachers must treat students as people to build personal and academic connections.
As teachers, we often refuse to comply with central office directives we don’t agree with, but then we demand students to follow our directives. What does freedom look like for teachers, what do we have to do in order for all of us to get free?
In my personal opinion, freedom for teachers involves the ability to design their own curriculum. With increasing standards and regulations that teachers must follow, it is becoming increasingly difficult to freely govern classrooms. Teachers are forced to follow a set of guidelines, and coursework becomes a way to check off boxes. Likewise, students are forced to follow classroom rules, hindering their potential. In order for us all to get free, we must increase voice and choice, implement advocacy for all, and create a democratic school.
“I understand school to be not only a place where young people must be treated as free persons but-more important-a place where they can learn, together, how to skillfully insist on their right to be treated as free people” ~ Carla Shalaby

Comments

  1. LindseyMay 5, 2019 at 6:36 PM

    Thank you for a very thoughtful reflection! As you state, it comes down to increased voice and choice and advocacy for all of our students. - Lindsey

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"The Unexpected Benefit of Celebrating Failure"

Video Summary: The speaker of the TED Talk on failure works for X- The Moon Shot Factory. At X, the goal is to uncover a huge problem, think of a radical solution, and then try to prove that you’re wrong. If you do the hardest parts first, it will keep you from hitting a dead end farther down the road. Discovering problems in a project sometimes puts in on a better path. For example, one team at X was working on a car that was almost in complete control and would only turn the power steering on if something went wrong. When the feedback came that this was a terrible idea, for drivers weren’t paying attention like they should have been, the team shifted their perspective and began working on a car that is in complete control. Screenshot from the video showing X’s thought process for projects Employees at X are rewarded and promoted if their idea fails in order for them to feel safe in failing. This idea stemmed from the consensus of being uncomfortable with working on risky...
2 comments
Read more

Girl Rising

Flyer of the SMC Common Read events The Saint Michael’s College Education Department has a common read each year. The common read for the fall 2018 semester was Girl Rising by Tanya Lee Stone. Three events were held over the course of the semester to deepen students’ and the public’s understanding of the book. I attended the author talk on October 22nd and I watched the film (which came before the book). The trailer for the movie is here for anyone interested in watching it. The author talk with Tanya Lee Stone was inspiring and moving. She began the talk by explaining how the Girl Rising movie was released in 2013. After watching it with her children, she noticed that they remembered more about the girls’ stories than about where the problem of education is in the world. She became passionate about slowing down and unpacking the information in the film in order to understand it better. This passion led to the idea of turning the movie into a book.   Stone c...
2 comments
Read more

ELL Placement

In my adolescent development class, we were assigned a weekly placement in a neighboring school. Different students in the class have different roles in each of the schools they visit. I have been paired up with a 16-year-old girl named Binsa from Nepal (note that I have changed her name for privacy and confidentiality). Binsa came to the United States in 2015 and is in the beginning levels for speaking, listening, reading, and writing English. Nepal is a Himalayan country in South Asia landlocked between China and India with the rough population of 27,474,000. The official language is Nepali and it's spoken by 44.6% of the population. Hindu is the predominant religion in Nepal with 81.3% of the population practicing. Nepal was closed to the outside world until the 1950s. It is one of the world's poorest countries with the bulk of the economy relying on tourism and aid from other countries. In April of 2015, a devastating earthquake hit, killing thousands of people, des...
1 comment
Read more